Introduction
Remittances play a crucial role in the economies of many developing countries. According to the World Bank, remittances to low- and middle-income countries reached $529 billion in 2018, surpassing foreign direct investment flows. With remittance flows continuing to increase steadily, policymakers are looking for ways to maximize the benefits of these funds for receiving households and communities.
One area that holds promise is financial regulations. Well-designed regulations can expand access to the formal financial system, reduce remittance costs, and protect consumers. This enables recipients to make the most of remittance income.
This article will examine the role of financial regulations in maximizing remittance benefits. It will cover the following key areas:
– The importance of remittances and how they are used
– Key challenges and risks in remittance markets
– Expanding access through proportional regulations
– Reducing transfer costs
– Protecting consumers against fraud and abuses
The Importance of Remittances and How They Are Used
Remittances from migrant workers overseas play a vital economic role in many developing countries. These funds help lift recipients out of poverty by providing income to cover basic needs. Remittances also drive economic growth by increasing consumer spending power. At the national level, remittance inflows bring in much-needed foreign currency.
Households use remittances to cover day-to-day expenses like food, housing, education, and medical care. Evidence shows that remittances tend to be spent wisely. Contrary to some perceptions, only a small portion goes towards luxury or conspicuous consumption.
In many cases, remittance solutions provide capital for small businesses and entrepreneurs. Recipients invest funds in livestock, equipment, retail shops, and other income-generating activities. Remittances also serve as an insurance policy against financial shocks from events like job loss, accidents, or natural disasters.
Therefore, remittances act as a critical lifeline and safety net for low-income families. Policymakers should view remittances foremost through a development lens. Regulations should aim to maximize the impact of these funds on reducing poverty and driving inclusive economic growth.
Key Challenges and Risks in Remittance Markets
However, several challenges prevent recipients and countries from fully benefiting from remittances:
High transfer costs – On average, sending $200 internationally costs around 7% in fees but sub-Saharan Africa shoulders the highest average cost of 9.4%. These high fees dig into the funds available for receiving households.
Lack of access to the formal financial system – Up to half of migrant workers are unbanked. They rely on expensive informal channels. Even on the receiving end, families often lack bank accounts to store or access funds.
Fraud and abuse risks – Senders and recipients are vulnerable to scams, predatory lending, and loss of funds through unregulated channels. These risks further limit market participation.
Market concentration – Just a handful of money transmitters like Western Union dominate remittance corridors. This lack of competition keeps fees high.
Regulatory inconsistencies – Varying regulations across jurisdictions hamper competition and raise compliance costs.
Expanding Access Through Proportional Regulations
To maximize benefits, regulations need to bring more remittance senders and recipients into the formal financial system. The guiding principles should be proportionality and responsible innovation.
With proportionality, regulations on new products and players should match the risks they pose and their stage of development. Overly restrictive requirements prevent innovative models from emerging. For instance, a 2019 study found that below a threshold of $1 million in transaction volume, increasing regulations correlated with a dramatic drop in new remittance providers entering that market.
Instead, policymakers can lower barriers to entry through tools like tiered licensing, pilot programs, and regulatory sandboxes. For example, the Bank of Jamaica allows new entrants to operate within limited parameters to test new remittance models.
Regulators should also enable responsible innovation by partnering with fintechs to develop cutting-edge services. Early collaboration allows rules to evolve with new technologies. One model is ‘test-and-learn’ regulation where requirements tighten gradually after assessing risks.
For instance, the Philippine Central Bank has worked closely with bitcoin exchanges to craft cryptocurrency regulations. This encouraged companies to formalize operations rather than risk crackdowns later on.
With supportive and adaptive policies, regulators can harness technology to expand access to remittance services.
Reducing Transfer Costs
Bringing down remittance fees also requires regulatory action in addition to competition and innovation. Three key steps can help reduce costs:
1. Lower compliance burdens
On the sender side, strict know-your-customer (KYC) and anti-money laundering (AML) rules often exclude migrants unable to provide official identification. Ethiopia’s central bank took an accommodating stance by working with informal community networks used by many low-income migrants. Compliance rules should align with senders’ capabilities.
2. Enable open and interoperable payment systems
On the recipient side, allowing non-bank payment providers to participate in settlement systems increases competition. The Central Bank of Kenya mandated interoperability among mobile money schemes, which led to dramatic growth. Compatible platforms let users easily switch providers and retain control over funds.
3. Improve transparency
Policymakers can require upfront disclosure of full transfer costs and offer comparison tools. The EU Payment Services Directive established these requirements along with capping fees. Consumers can make informed choices and providers feel pressure to offer fair pricing.
The World Bank estimates that better regulations could reduce average remittance costs by up to 5 percentage points globally. The resulting savings would release more than $16 billion to recipients. Policymakers should prioritize affordability.
Protecting Consumers Against Fraud and Abuse
Finally, remittance regulations aim to mitigate fraud, scams, and predatory behavior targeting consumers. However, rules focused narrowly on eliminating the risks of new technologies often simply push users towards unregulated and more dangerous options.
The answer lies in proportionate consumer protection without restricting market evolution. Regulators should:
– Set conduct requirements like fair treatment and transparent terms for new services
– Implement strong recourse mechanisms for users to recover lost funds
– Partner with providers on awareness campaigns and fraud prevention
For instance, the Smart Campaign established industry standards for consumer protection practices tailored to mobile banking and fintechs. Regulations based on principles rather than specific technologies can accommodate innovation.
Meanwhile, rapid recourse channels like ombudsmen, arbitration bodies, and community mediators give users confidence. Kenya instituted a fast-track mechanism to quickly freeze and recover stolen mobile money.
With supportive action, regulators can protect consumers while enabling new products to emerge. Proactive collaboration with providers is key.
Conclusion
As remittance flows continue growing, financial regulations have an important role to play in maximizing development impact for recipients worldwide. Regulators should craft policies that expand access, reduce costs, and protect consumers in a proportionate manner.
With the right approach, cross-border digital payments can become an even more powerful tool for reducing poverty and driving financial inclusion. Policymakers need to view remittances through a development lens and implement reforms that enable innovation, affordability, and safety.
Digipay is a fintech platform that provides cashless banking, online payments, virtual cards, and digital financial solutions.
DigiPay.Guru is a globally recognized fintech solution provider that offers advanced digital payment solutions to banks, fintechs, financial institutions, NBFCs, and businesses. Our comprehensive suite called DG Bank provides products and services such as Mobile Money, Agency Banking, International Remittance, eKYC, Prepaid Cards, Merchant Acquiring, and Scan & Thru.
We help businesses design solutions to revolutionize financial markets by building mature, flexible, customizable, and future-proof digital platforms. Our solutions are available in both “License Version” and “SaaS Model”.
